Are Cheap Tires Worth It?

A Clear Guide to New Tires, Used Tires, and Smart Tire Investing

Choosing tires is one of the most important decisions you make for your vehicle, yet it’s one of the places many drivers try to cut costs. That raises a key question we hear all the time: Are cheap tires worth it? At Colony Tire & Service, we want drivers in North Carolina, South Carolina, and Virginia to make confident tire decisions that protect safety, comfort, and long-term value.

This page provides straightforward answers about cheap tires and helps you compare new tires vs. used tires so you can decide what’s right for your driving style and budget.

What Do People Mean by “Cheap Tires”?

When people talk about cheap tires, they usually mean one of two things:

• New budget tires – new tires from lower-cost brands
• Used tires – previously driven tires sold at a discount

Both can save money upfront, but they deliver very different performance, safety, and durability.

Before you pick either option, it’s important to understand the differences.

New Budget Tires: Pros and Cons

New budget tires are brand-new but priced lower than premium brands. They are built to meet basic safety standards and get you down the road without breaking the bank.

Advantages

• New with full tread and manufacturing warranty
• Predictable performance in everyday driving
• Legal and safe if they meet industry standards
• Often better fuel economy than worn tires

Things to Consider

• May wear faster than premium tires
• Can be noisier or less refined
• May not perform as well in extreme weather or performance driving

Are cheap new tires worth it?

Yes,  if your driving needs are basic (commuting, errands, moderate speeds, dry/wet weather) and you choose a budget tire from a reputable brand. However, saving money up front may mean replacing them sooner than higher-tier tires.

If you want help choosing tires that balance cost and quality, our tire selection and recommendation team can guide you through the best options for your budget and vehicle.

Used Tires: What You Should Know

Potential Advantages

• Lower initial price
• Can be okay for temporary or spare use

Major Drawbacks

• Unknown history: age, damage, repairs, and wear patterns
• Uneven wear can affect handling and braking
• Older tires dry-rot even if tread looks good
• No warranty or performance guarantee

Because of these risks, used tires are rarely worth it for daily driving. On vehicles that carry passengers, tow loads, or drive at highway speeds, the safety trade-offs are significant.

For most drivers, investing in new tires, even budget options, is a safer choice. If you’re considering used tires as a temporary solution, ask our team to conduct a tire safety check first.

Why Tire Quality Matters

Tires are the only part of your vehicle that touches the road. Cheap tires that cut corners can lead to:

• Poor braking distance
• Less traction in rain or cold
• Faster wear and replacement costs
• Rough or noisy ride quality

Spending a little more upfront on the right tire can save money over time by lasting longer and performing better.

You can explore quality tire options on our tire inventory page to see how different price points compare in real terms.

New Tires vs Used Tires: Side-by-Side

Feature	New Budget Tires	Used Tires
Safety	High (new tread + no damage)	Low to unknown
Tread Life	Full expected life	Limited, unpredictable
Warranty	Often included	None
Price	Moderate	Low
Performance	Predictable	Risky
Value for Daily Driving	Good	Poor

For regular driving, new tires, even inexpensive ones,  are generally a smarter investment than used tires. Used tires may seem cheap, but their hidden risks often outweigh the savings.

When Cheap Tires Can Be Worth It

Budget tires can be a good fit when:

• You drive mainly around town
• You don’t carry heavy loads or tow
• You stick to moderate speeds
• You want a safe, economical choice

But even budget tires should be chosen with care. Not all “cheap” tires are created equal, and price alone doesn’t guarantee quality or safety.

If you want personalized guidance, our tire team can match you with the best tire options for your driving habits.

How to Decide What’s Right for You

Ask yourself:

• How many miles do you drive each year?
• Do you drive mostly highways or city streets?
• Do you encounter rain, heat, or winter weather?
• Do you carry passengers or tow loads?

Your answers will help determine whether a budget tire is a good fit or whether investing in a mid-range or premium tire will save you money and headaches in the long run.

At Colony Tire & Service, we support you with local expertise and honest recommendations to make the best choice.
If you’re ready to compare tires side by side or need help determining what will work best for your vehicle, visit our tire comparison page or find your nearest location to contact us today.

---